Two Little Red Hens Bakery

Upper East Side
1652 Second Ave.
between E.85th/E.86th Sts.

P: 212.452.0476

An Upper East Side American bakery with old fashioned pies, cakes and cookies, all with a home-made style quality and flavor. 

What's great:
Old fashioned apple pies, lemon tarts, apple crumb bars, brownies, mini-cupcakes that are a perfect replica of their larger, icing-loaded counterparts, and your favorite cookies are just some of the stand-outs.

What to know:
If you want something for a specific event, especially a holiday like Thanksgiving, make sure to place an order in advance.  They will do custom cakes working from a dizzying menu of choices for cake, icings and fillings -- 3 days advance notice required.  Their web site has all the details.