McNulty's Tea & Coffee Co.
109 Christopher St.
between Bleecker/Hudson Sts.
A popular West Village coffee and tea store. They still call themselves "purveyors of rare teas and choice coffees" and the slogan fits. Excellent selection with a knowledgeable and helpful staff.
In business since 1895, this store is a Village treasure. They're open 7-days a week and take orders online and over the phone.